2011年10月14日Round Rock Research LLC於美國德拉威爾地方法院提起關於電腦零組件之訴訟,控告Dell、Acer及Asus三家廠商侵犯其專利權。
本案系爭專利US5255109、US5787174、US5938764、US5991843、US6002613、US7101727、US7138823、US7285979及US7389369可分為下列幾類:
DDR記憶體技術 |
US6002613、US7138823、US7285979及US7389369 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:Streak and Inspiron Duo tablet computers; Inspiron, Latitude, and Alienware notebook computers; Inspiron "all-in-one" computers; and Inspiron, Alienware, XPS, Precision Tower, Precision Mobile, Vostro, and Optiplex desktop computers。
Acer被控侵權的系爭產品有:TravelMate and Aspire notebook computers; Aspire netbook computers; All-in-One, Predator, Aspire, and Veriton desktop computers; Gateway LT netbook computers;Gateway EC, ID, and NV netbook computers; and Gateway One desktop computers。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:Essentio and Eee desktop N series of notebook computers; Eee tablets; U, N, F, M, X, G, K, A, F,K, and B notebook N series of notebook computers; T and R servers; and AMD and Intel series motherboards。 |
CMOS 影像感測器 |
US7101727 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:Streak mobile phones。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:K52 line of notebook N series of notebook computers。 |
應用USB 3.0之電腦系統 |
US5991843 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:Inspiron, XPS, Latitude, Alienware and Vostro notebook computers and Alienware, XPS, Precision Tower, Precision Mobile, and Vostro desktop computers。
Acer被控侵權的系爭產品有:Aspire Timeline X, TravelMate Timeline X, and Gateway NV notebook computers; ICONIA tablets; Veriton desktop computers; and Gateway FX desktop computers。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:All-in-One PC computers and N series of notebook computers。 |
以非揮發性記憶體儲存BIOS的技術 |
US5938764 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:Precision Tower line of desktop computers。
Acer被控侵權的系爭產品有:TravelMate line of computers。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:N series of notebook computers。 |
藍芽及802.11無線通訊技術 |
US5787174 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:Venue mobile phones; Streak and Inspiron Duo tablet computers; Inspiron, Latitude, and Alienware notebook computers; Inspiron "all-in-one" computers; and Inspiron, Alienware, XPS, Precision Tower, Precision Mobile, Vostro, and Optiplex desktop computers。
Acer被控侵權的系爭產品有:Aspire and Predator notebook computers and Revo and Veriton desktop computers。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:Eee Slate tablet computers; CM desktop computers; Eee "All-in-One" personal computers; Bamboo, U, UL, F, N, G, K, and B series notebook computers; Internet Radio series internet radios; and Skype Phone AiGuru S2 internet phones。 |
LCD散熱技術 |
US5255109 |
Dell被控侵權的系爭產品有:SR2320L LCD monitor。
Acer被控侵權的系爭產品有:H243H bmid LCD monitor。
Asus被控侵權的系爭產品有:VW246H LCD monitor。 |
Source:Kuo,科技政策研究與資訊中心—科技產業資訊室整理,2011/10
本案系爭專利
Publication |
Title |
Assignee |
Pub. Date |
Filed |
IPC Code |
US7285979 |
Apparatus and method for independent control of on-die termination for output buffers of a memory device |
Micron Technology, Inc. |
2007-10-23 |
2006-10-26 |
H03K 17/16 |
US7138823 |
Apparatus and method for independent control of on-die termination for output buffers of a memory device |
Micron Technology, Inc. |
2006-11-21 |
2005-01-20 |
H03K 17/16 |
US7101727 |
Passivation planarization |
Micron Technology, Inc. |
2006-09-05 |
2004-06-29 |
H01L 21/00 |
US6002613 |
Data communication for memory |
Micron, Technology, Inc. |
1999-12-14 |
1997-11-10 |
G11C 11/401 |
US5991843 |
Method and system for concurrent computer transaction processing |
Micron Electronics, Inc. |
1999-11-23 |
1998-10-20 |
G06F 13/36 |
US5938764 |
Apparatus for improved storage of computer system configuration information |
Micron Electronics, Inc. |
1999-08-17 |
1996-10-23 |
G06F 9/445 |
US5787174 |
Remote identification of integrated circuit |
Micron Technology, Inc. |
1998-07-28 |
1995-11-02 |
G01S 13/75 |
US5255109 |
Heat dissipating LCD display |
PC Tech Inc. |
1993-10-19 |
1992-04-23 |
G02F 1/133 |
Round Rock Research LLC創立在2010年的專利授權公司,Round Rock Research LLC曾授權給APPLE、SONY、MICRON、SAMSUNG、NOKIA、HTC、IBM及LG等大廠,HTC亦曾受到Round Rock Research LLC的訴訟攻擊,請參閱本網站前期文章【專利授權公司Round Rock控告HTC侵犯手機記憶體晶片專利】,雙方於2011年4月和解。
Round Rock 公司創辦人John Desmarais是具有化工及法律背景的律師,2007年任職於 Kirkland&Ellis事務所時,曾代理Alcatel-Lucent對微軟的MP3訴訟,並讓微軟付出15.2億美元的天價賠償。(823字;表1)
表一、專利訴訟案件基本資料:Round Rock Research對Dell、Acer及Asus提起電腦零組件訴訟
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e404c/e404cf11341b705ddc7d73217b3e0d0ea26ad5f8" alt="pclass_11_A247.gif"
Source:Kuo,科技政策研究與資訊中心—科技產業資訊室整理,2011/10
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------