原告： Intellectual Ventures
2012年12月12日Intellectual Ventures告Check Point Software等公司案，法官作出4件系爭專利權利項語句解釋(Claim Construction)命令，有US6,460,050、US6,073,142、US5,987,610、及US7,506,155。
Claim語句： an indication of the characteristic
解釋：a descriptor of the content (e.g., spam, virus, junk email, copyrighted)
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： an organizational hierarchy of a business, the hierarchy including a plurality of roles, each role associated with a user
解釋：a business`s rankings of its roles, containing multiple levels and each level comprising at least one organization role to which at least one individual is assigned
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： automatically reviewing the [email message/data object] after a specified time interval to determine an action to be applied
解釋：computer determination of an action to be applied to [the email message/data object] after a specified period of time
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： characterizing the files on the server system based on said digital content identifiers received relative to other digital identifiers collected in the database
解釋：classifying the files on the server system by comparing their digital content identifiers to other digital identifiers collected in the database
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： [combines/combining] the [email message/data object] with a new distribution list ... and a rule history ...
解釋：combining the e-mail message [or data object], a new distribution list, and a rule history, for delivery together, where a rule history identifies each of the [at least one] business rule( s) whose antecedent condition was satisfied by the e-mail message [or data object]
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： converting ... from an executable format to a non-executable format
解釋：transforming the executable code into a version that cannot open any processes or applications
系爭專利：7,506,155
Claim語句： database of business rules/business rules
解釋：storage of statements that each specify one or more antecedent condition(s) and the consequent action(s) to be applied when the specified antecedent condition(s) are satisfied; ultimately only a single consequence results for each business rule
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： data file(s)
解釋：a collection of any type of text or binary data that retains cohesion when presented to a user
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： deactivating the hypertext link
解釋：rendering the hypertext link inoperable as an executable link to the specified URL, while leaving alphanumeric text that is identifiable as a hypertext link
系爭專利：7,506,155
Claim語句： determining ... whether each received content identifier matches a characteristic of other identifiers
解釋：determining ... whether each received content identifier has the same characteristic as other content identifiers
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： digital content identifier created using a mathematical algorithm unique to the message content
解釋：a digital content identifier (defined above) created using a mathematical algorithm; the identifier being particular to the message content (e.g., every time the same algorithm is run on the same content the same value results)
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： file content identifier/file .content ID/digital content identifier/digital content ID
解釋：A digital content identifier reflecting at least a portion of the content of a data file, but not constituting merely an excised portion of that data file. For clarity, an excised portion of the content of a data file that has been encoded and/or compressed for transmission is not a [file content identifier/file content ID/digital content identifier/digital content ID]. However, the presence of an excised portion of a data file (whether encoded, compressed or otherwise) does not prevent something other than that excised portion from being classified as a [file content identifier/file content ID/digital content identifier/digital content ID].
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： file content identifier generator agent(s)
解釋：software running on a computer that creates and transmits file content identifiers to a second tier system
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： forwarding the non-executable format
解釋：forwarding the version that cannot open any processes or applications
系爭專利：7,506,155
Claim語句： identification code
解釋：a set of symbols that identify
系爭專利：5,987,610
Claim語句： identify the existence or absence of said characteristic
解釋：identify whether or not the message is of a certain type or classification
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： indicating the presence or absence of a characteristic
解釋：indicating the presence or absence of a characteristic (e.g., spam, virus, copyright, bulk email)
系爭專利：6,460,050
Claim語句： persistently storing
解釋：storing for extended periods of time (for example, hours or days as opposed to seconds)
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： primary message store ... for receiving and non-persistently storing e-mail messages
解釋：普通意義
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： retains an appearance, human readability, and semantic content of the e-mail message
解釋：retains substantially the same appearance, human readability, and semantic content of the emailmessage, such that all or substantially allalphanumeric text in the email message remainshuman readable
系爭專利：7,506,155
Claim語句： routing a call between a calling party and a called party of a telephone network
解釋：transmitting a voice or data transmission between a party initiating a voice or data transmission and a party receiving a voice or data transmission
系爭專利：5,987,610
Claim語句： rule engine
解釋：a mechanism that applies the business rules, in order to determine a set of actions (one or more) to be applied
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： secondary message store ... for receiving there from, and persistently storing an e-mail message
解釋：普通意義
系爭專利：6,073,142
Claim語句： within the telephone network
解釋：in the voice or data network connecting the calling party and called party, exclusive of the networks and gateway nodes of the called party and calling party
系爭專利：5,987,610